Fluoride vs Hydroxyapatite in Toothpaste: A Comparative Analysis


|   Written by:


In the realm of oral health and hygiene, the role of toothpaste is paramount. It is our first line of defense against dental caries, gum diseases, and other oral health issues. Over the years, the composition of toothpaste has evolved significantly, with two key ingredients often being the focus of attention: fluoride and hydroxyapatite.

Fluoride, a mineral lauded for its cavity-fighting properties, has been the standard active ingredient in toothpaste for decades. However, a newer contender, hydroxyapatite, has recently emerged, promising a similar level of protection with some additional benefits.

This article delves into a comprehensive comparison between fluoride and hydroxyapatite in toothpaste. We will explore the roles and mechanisms of these compounds, their history, effectiveness, safety, and affordability. We aim to provide an understanding of both these ingredients, helping you make an informed choice when it comes to selecting your toothpaste. Whether you’re a dental professional, a health-conscious consumer, or simply curious, this in-depth exploration provides valuable insights into the science behind your daily dental care regimen.fluoride toothpaste vs Hydroxyapatite toothpaste

What is fluoride?

Fluoride is a natural mineral found in various amounts in almost all water supplies. It is also present in some foods and can be synthetically added to other products, most notably toothpaste. Recognized for its significant role in oral health, fluoride has been incorporated in dental care products and public water supplies in many regions worldwide.

The use of fluoride in dentistry dates back to the early 20th century. Researchers discovered that people who drank naturally fluoridated water had fewer cavities, leading to the introduction of fluoride in toothpaste and other oral care products.

How does fluoride toothpaste work?

Fluoride toothpaste works by promoting the remineralization of tooth enamel, the hard outer layer of our teeth that protects them from decay. The process begins when the fluoride ions present in the toothpaste react with the saliva in your mouth. This reaction forms a temporary, protective layer of fluoride on your teeth.

The fluoride then interacts with the tooth enamel, promoting the replacement of lost mineral content and making the teeth more resistant to acid attacks from plaque bacteria and sugars in the mouth. This action helps prevent tooth decay and cavities.

What is hydroxyapatite (HAp)?

Hydroxyapatite, often abbreviated as HAp, is a naturally occurring mineral and the main component of tooth enamel and dentin. It’s also found in bones, making up about 70% of their structure. Hydroxyapatite is primarily composed of calcium, phosphorus, and oxygen atoms arranged in a crystalline structure.

In the context of dental health, hydroxyapatite is of particular interest because of its biocompatibility with the human body and its role in maintaining and restoring tooth enamel.

How does hydroxyapatite toothpaste work?

Like fluoride, hydroxyapatite toothpaste works to protect and restore tooth enamel, but it does so in a slightly different way. Hydroxyapatite toothpaste contains nano-sized particles of the mineral, which can bond directly with tooth enamel.squeezing out toothpaste hydroxyapatite

When you brush your teeth with hydroxyapatite toothpaste, these particles adhere to the surface of your teeth, filling in tiny gaps and fissures in the enamel. This process can help to repair minor damage, prevent future decay, and even whiten teeth by providing a smoother, more reflective surface.

Who invented hydroxyapatite toothpaste?

The concept of using hydroxyapatite in toothpaste was first developed in Japan in the 1970s. The Japanese company Sangi Co., Ltd. introduced the world’s first hydroxyapatite toothpaste in 1978. The product, marketed under the brand name Apagard, was based on research conducted by Dr. Kazue Yamagishi, a notable figure in the field of dental research.

Recommendations on how to use nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste

Known for its remarkable remineralizing properties, nano-hydroxyapatite is a biocompatible material that closely resembles the mineral form of hydroxyapatite found in human teeth and bones.

But how to use it correctly? Here’s a guide:

  1. Choose the Right Product: Start by selecting a high-quality nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste from a reputable brand. Look for products that specifically list nano-hydroxyapatite as an active ingredient and check for any additional components that might benefit your specific dental needs, such as ingredients for sensitive teeth or natural whiteners.
  2. Regular Brushing: Use your nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste at least twice a day. Apply a pea-sized amount of toothpaste to a soft-bristled toothbrush.
  3. Proper Brushing Technique: Brush gently with a circular motion, ensuring that you cover all surfaces of each tooth. Spend at least two minutes during each brushing session to allow the nano-hydroxyapatite ample time to bond with the tooth enamel.
  4. Don’t Rinse Immediately: After brushing, spit out the excess toothpaste but avoid rinsing your mouth immediately with water. Leaving a trace amount of toothpaste on your teeth can prolong the remineralizing action. If the feeling of not rinsing is too unpleasant, you can opt for a minimal water rinse or use a mouthwash designed to work with remineralizing toothpastes.
  5. Consistency is Key: As with any dental care product, consistent use is crucial. The benefits of nano-hydroxyapatite build over time with regular use.
  6. Complement with Good Dental Habits: Combine the use of nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste with flossing, using an antibacterial mouthwash, and maintaining a diet low in sugary and acidic foods to maximize dental health.
  7. Regular Dental Check-ups: Continue to visit your dentist regularly for professional cleanings and check-ups. Discuss the use of nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste with your dentist to ensure it fits well within your overall dental care regimen.

Which is better?

EfficacyFluoride has been extensively studied and proven to be effective in preventing tooth decay and cavities. It works by promoting the remineralization of tooth enamel, making teeth more resistant to acid attacks.Hydroxyapatite has also been shown to be effective at preventing tooth decay. It works by bonding directly to the tooth enamel, filling in tiny gaps and fissures. Some studies suggest it can be as effective as fluoride, but these findings are less numerous and often smaller in scale.
SafetyGenerally safe for most people when used appropriately. However, high concentrations or accidental ingestion can lead to health issues, including dental fluorosis in children and potential bone and neurological problems in extreme cases. Some people also have ethical objections to the use of fluoride.Hydroxyapatite is considered safe and biocompatible, with no known health risks. It is not associated with any toxicity or overexposure concerns because it’s a natural component of human teeth and bones.
AffordabilityFluoride toothpaste is widely available and usually affordable, available in a vast range of brands and price points.Hydroxyapatite toothpaste tends to be more expensive than fluoride toothpaste. It is generally found in premium or specialty oral care products.
AvailabilityFluoride toothpaste is widely available worldwide, in supermarkets, pharmacies, and online stores.Hydroxyapatite toothpaste, while growing in popularity, is not as readily available as fluoride toothpaste. It is more likely to be found in health food stores, specialty dental stores, or online.

How does hydroxyapatite compare to fluoride in efficacy?

When it comes to efficacy in toothpaste, both fluoride and hydroxyapatite have been shown to be effective at preventing tooth decay. However, fluoride has been studied more extensively and has a longer history of use in dentistry.

Fluoride works by promoting the remineralization of tooth enamel, making teeth more resistant to decay. Hydroxyapatite, on the other hand, works by bonding directly to the tooth enamel, filling in tiny gaps and fissures.fluoride toothpaste heart shape

Some studies have found that hydroxyapatite toothpaste can be as effective as fluoride toothpaste at preventing cavities. However, these studies are fewer in number and often smaller in scale than those examining fluoride toothpaste.

Benefits of hydroxyapatite over fluoride toothpastes

Despite the proven effectiveness of fluoride, hydroxyapatite toothpastes do offer certain advantages. First, hydroxyapatite is not associated with any known health risks, making it a safer choice for those concerned about potential side effects of fluoride.

Second, hydroxyapatite toothpaste can provide a more natural whitening effectby smoothing the enamel surface, reflecting light more effectively. This is a distinct cosmetic advantage for many users. Lastly, hydroxyapatite toothpaste may be a more biocompatible solution, being the primary component of human teeth and bones, hence potentially offering a more natural mode of action.

Is fluorapatite stronger than hydroxyapatite?

Fluorapatite is indeed considered to be stronger and more resistant to acid than hydroxyapatite. This is because fluoride ions can replace hydroxide ions in the hydroxyapatite crystal structure to form fluorapatite, a more stable and less soluble compound. This is the basis of fluoride’s benefit in toothpaste; it encourages the formation of fluorapatite on the tooth surface, enhancing resistance to acid attacks and consequently reducing the risk of cavities.

The history of fluoride

The history of fluoride in dental care is a fascinating journey. Fluoride’s dental benefits were first discovered in the early 20th century, when researchers noticed lower rates of tooth decay in communities with naturally high fluoride levels in their water. This led to the practice of water fluoridation, which began in the United States in the 1940s.

The first fluoride toothpastes were introduced in the 1950s, and their use has since become widespread. Today, fluoride is recognized by the World Health Organization and other health authorities as a key factor in oral health.

The remineralization and demineralization process

Tooth enamel constantly undergoes a process of demineralization and remineralization. When you eat, the sugars in food interact with bacteria in your mouth to produce acids. These acids can dissolve the minerals in tooth enamel, a process known as demineralization, which can lead to tooth decay and cavities.Fluoride vs Hydroxyapatite in Toothpaste

However, this process is naturally counteracted by remineralization. Saliva contains minerals such as calcium and phosphate, which it deposits onto the enamel surface. Fluoride, whether from toothpaste, water, or other sources, assists this process by forming a more acid-resistant mineral on the tooth surface, fluorapatite.

Should you use fluoridated or non-fluoridated toothpaste?

The choice between fluoridated and non-fluoridated toothpaste is a personal one and should take into account several factors. For instance, those at high risk of tooth decay, such as people with a history of cavities, may benefit more from fluoride toothpaste. However, those with ethical or health concerns about fluoride may prefer hydroxyapatite toothpaste or other non-fluoridated alternatives.

What are the benefits of using fluoridated toothpaste?

Fluoridated toothpaste has been proven to help prevent cavities and tooth decay. The fluoride in the toothpaste promotes remineralization, making tooth enamel more resistant to acid attacks. It can also reverse early signs of tooth decay.

Fluoride toothpaste is particularly beneficial for those at high risk of dental decay, such as those with a history of cavities, poor oral hygiene, or a high-sugar diet. It’s also recommended for children, as their developing teeth are particularly prone to decay.

What does the researches say?


  1. Community Effectiveness of Public Water Fluoridation in Reducing Children’s Dental Disease – This research by Armfield JM, published in “Public Health Reports” in 2010, discusses the effectiveness of water fluoridation in reducing tooth decay in children. It concluded that water fluoridation significantly decreases the occurrence of tooth decay.
  2. Topical fluoride for caries prevention: Executive summary of the updated clinical recommendations and supporting systematic review – In this study by Weyant RJ et al., published in “The Journal of the American Dental Association” in 2013, the authors found that professionally applied fluoride gel is effective in preventing dental caries in high-risk individuals.


  1. Remineralization effects of xylitol on demineralized enamel – This experiment by Mei ML et al., published in the “Journal of Electron Microscopy” in 2013, found that microcrystalline hydroxyapatite may have a remineralizing effect on enamel, making it a potential treatment for dental caries.
  2. Hydroxyapatite and its use as a bone graft material – In this review by LeGeros RZ, published in “Dental Clinics of North America” in 1991, the author discusses the use of hydroxyapatite in bone grafting and its potential application in dentistry. The review suggests that hydroxyapatite has properties that may be beneficial in dental restorative procedures.
  3. Clinical evaluation of a toothpaste containing calcium sodium phosphosilicate (novamin) and a toothpaste containing potassium nitrate for the treatment of dentinal hypersensitivity – A study by Pradeep AR et al., published in the “Journal of Periodontology” in 2010, found that a toothpaste containing hydroxyapatite was effective at treating dentinal hypersensitivity.

Awesome! Share to:

More Cinoll Articles